9Questions is our Q&A series featuring key decision-makers in the corporate credit markets — get in touch if you know who we should be talking to!
In recent years, Europe has become more than just a popular holiday destination for Americans wanting a ‘Eurosummer’ — it has also become the new hunting ground for direct lenders seeking better pricing and less competition.
Chicago-based manager Adams Street Partners has its roots as a private equity allocator, investing in sponsors as early as 1979, when it established the industry’s first fund-of-funds. It set up its private credit strategy in 2016, seeing an opportunity to leverage its LP status to win deals in sponsor-backed direct lending.
Adams Street added a European private credit team in 2022 to test if the theory would hold true across the Atlantic.
In April, the $70bn-AUM firm closed its third private credit fund at $7.5bn, with 40% of capital coming from non-US LPs — bringing its total private credit assets under management to $15bn.
9fin sat down with James Charalambides, head of European private credit at Adams Street, to discuss what’s next, what it was like to set up shop and where it sees the hottest opportunities in Europe.
1. When Adams Street launched its European private credit strategy in 2022, Bill Sacher said that “Europe is fertile ground for sponsor-backed private credit deals”. Is that still true?
Absolutely. From an overall market perspective, while the European direct lending market is smaller than the US today, it's also expected to grow faster over the next five years or so.
There are a few different drivers for that. One of them is the retrenchment of commercial banks in the market. That happened more than a decade ago in the US but it's still happening in Europe, which is creating a lot of white space for private credit. You also have the fact that the European market has historically been a bilateral market. As the sector grows and managers’ AUM grows, there’s more club deals and private credit has the ability to finance larger transactions.
The other factor is that there's a long-term supply-demand imbalance. If you look at the dry powder in private equity funds today and you assume a typical debt-for-equity structure for the transactions, the demand for financing is probably about five times larger than the dry powder in private credit funds.
Then from an Adams Street perspective, Europe is particularly fertile ground because we've been investing in European private equity funds since the 80s and have had offices in London since 1997. On top of that, we don't do buyouts directly ourselves so we don't compete with those sponsors. It really puts us in a unique position because we have these really well-established institutional relationships with private equity firms. It not only gives us access to deal flow, but it also means that when we find a deal we like, our ability to win that deal is a lot higher, so that allows us to really be selective.
2. Which geographies and sectors are you seeing the most opportunities for deployment in Europe?
The core mid market continues to be our focus. We define that as about €150m to €750m EV.
If you look at smaller companies of less than €150m EV, they tend to do okay in the good times. But in the bad times, their default rates tend to be a little bit higher and recovery rates tend to be significantly lower. They're very hard to restructure, they're not necessarily missed in their market as they're not a key player, et cetera.
Then if you look at the upper end, companies above €800m or so EV, they have access to public markets and in simple terms, we don't like competing with BSLs. There's very little diligence on the way in — they don't ask for maintenance financial covenants, documentation is loose, pricing is lower, et cetera. The core mid market is where you have the high quality scale companies, but you also have the terms and economics that we really want in private credit maintenance financial covenants.
In terms of geographies, we have a pretty broad palate. We've done deals in the Nordics, the UK, Benelux, France, and Germany. But our mandate is very much pan-European. While I'd say those geographies I've just named are our core focus, we'll also look at deals outside of those regions.
In terms of sectors, defence has been interesting for us. There's been a very strong commitment from European governments to invest in the space, so it’s becoming more investable. At the same time, we also have a lot of experience of investing in defence in the US, meaning we can draw on the expertise we've built there to do deals in Europe. Meanwhile, a lot of European players haven't really done much defence historically because a) there was less funding to the sector from governments, and b) LPs considered it to be non-ESG friendly and didn't necessarily want to be in the space.
3. Adams Street closed its third private credit fund in April. How did conversations with LPs go during the final sprint of fundraising given headlines coming out about private credit at the time?
The sense of overall uncertainty had been heightened for LPs, and as a result, they were a little bit more focused on trying to find managers with the ability to perform well in more difficult times.
I do think a lot of headlines have been overblown, but there are some realities to this. We are seeing generally across the board a little bit more pressure on companies and on earnings. We're seeing a few more restructurings. If we do see a cycle, I think defaults are going to rise, and if that’s the case, we'll see that not all managers have been equal in their discipline.
What really resonated among LPs is that we have a distinct competitive advantage because we're very long standing partner to private equity firms. Secondly, our realised loss rate to date is 0%, and that's across all of our investments in each of our credit funds since inception of the platform because we’re focused on investing well over deployment.
4. Can you talk about what it’s like to do sponsor-backed deals amid wider M&A slowdowns?
When we set up our team in London in late 2022/early 2023, there was a lot of market disruption and dislocation, which meant there wasn’t a lot of M&A happening. From a pure mechanical perspective, if there's less deals to look at, there's less deals to do.
But it was a very interesting time for us to come into the market because we saw a lot of lenders pulling back because they didn't know what to do, so the sponsors that we worked with really valued us being there in those difficult times.
5. So what are your thoughts on non-sponsored lending, especially as the sponsor-backed space faces more competition and higher pricing pressures?
We are absolutely focused on sponsor-backed transactions.
There are some intrinsic features [of sponsor-backed deals] that make them more appealing from a risk perspective. For example, when a sponsor buys a company there's an arm's-length valuation that comes with a cash equity check going in the deal right away, resulting in pretty attractive equity cushions in the deals we do. There’s also pretty thorough diligence, and once [a sponsor] buys a business, they tend to have better governance, professionalised management teams, better quality information et cetera.
Finally, if a deal does go wrong, sponsors can support the business by putting in more cash and continuing to invest in the company because they have available capital. That's not always the case with non-sponsored companies, who could have a family or the management team as shareholders. The other piece is, if you look at restructuring a company, it's a lot easier when management aren’t also key shareholders of the business as it can make things pretty complicated.
Fundamentally, the only way you drive alpha in private credit, and direct lending in particular, is by not making losses. You know what your interest is, you know what the nominal amount of the debt is, you know what the fees are that you got on the way in. You can't overperform that. You can only underperform it. So while you might get a little bit more margin on non-sponsored deals, we think the incremental risk they come with doesn't necessarily justify them.
6. How have recent fears around private credit and software impacted your origination, underwriting or portfolio construction process?
Fundamentally, there hasn't been a direct impact on how we underwrite. We've been investing defensively for some time. We look for companies that will perform well through different market environments, including recessions, high inflation periods, supply chain disruptions et cetera, and we continue to look for the same characteristics.
It's the same on software. AI is not something completely new. We've been thinking about AI risk and having it as part of our underwriting framework for software and other sectors for quite some time. The way we think about the world is we want to pick the best companies, and we're focused on bottom-up, company-level diligence. We also look to mitigate risk through top-down portfolio management techniques, including concentration monitoring. In general, we don't like having high levels of sector concentration. Our view is you shouldn't be managing concentration on a reactive basis, you should be managing it on a proactive basis. The result of that is our software exposure is about 10% across our private credit portfolios today, which is significantly lower than broader market estimates.
We saw something similar in 2022 and 2023 when we saw market dislocation. Some lenders in the market all of a sudden reduced their bite size on deals when they realised that they had too much single name concentration in their portfolios.
What it has maybe changed is, in periods of time where other lenders are having issues in their portfolio or struggling to assess what to do with headline risks — it creates opportunities for us because when our competitors pull back, we are able to find companies with the same high quality at slightly better terms.
7. What was one challenge and one highlight of setting up Adams Street’s European private credit presence?
So I joined right at the end of 2022 and we really started to ramp the business in 2023. And look, it was interesting market timing with a lot of market disruption and dislocation. The Ukraine war was showing no signs of coming to an end; people were realising it wasn't going to be a short lived thing. Few would have thought it would still be ongoing today. Meanwhile, when I left my previous firm, it was a very hot market with lots of M&A. I had to sit on the beach for some time for contractual reasons, and when I rejoined the market, it had visibly cooled so there wasn’t much deal volume
From a highlight perspective — the theory when we set up the European platform was that we hoped the firm’s existing relationships with sponsors were going to unlock transactions for us. And from the get go, we did establish ourselves as a very credible lead lender in the mid market, capable of fully underwriting and leading sizeable mid-market transactions with super high quality sponsors. I think that's only possible because of the fact that we have all these Adams Street relationships and advantages.
8. What’s next for you and your team?
To date, we've invested about $1.5bn of capital into committed financings for 14 borrowers. We’re the lead lender in over 95% of our deals, which also have really nice credit stats. Our average leverage is 4.6x with equity cushions of about 60%, meaning we’re lending to high-quality businesses where sponsors are putting a lot of money into the business ahead of us.
The next area of focus for us is continuing to build out our European private credit platform, including expanding our capabilities, team, and presence in the region.
9. How do you like to relax?
There’s actually a lot going on this summer, so I’m not sure I’ll have time to relax, I've been busy with renovating an old house for some time, which is keeping me pretty busy outside of work, so not a ton of holidays coming.
But I like to run. I live in the countryside, and I like to go for long runs in the fields and the hills. I have to say, this time of year, at sunset, it's always re-energising to see some deer and just be outside.






